Why motivational theories don work

Offer your help. Anxious or fearful employees often respond positively to assistance with their approach to the task as well as to reminders that they are capable and can succeed with more effort. If the emotions do not soften with time and effort or if they spring from outside the workplace, for example, it may be advisable to help the employee access counseling.

How to help an employee out of this trap: Help the employee think clearly about the cause of their struggles with a task. Helping the employee identify exactly why the task seems insurmountable can help them move past such avoidance. With each of these four motivation traps, the trick is to think more comprehensively about what stops employees from initiating, persisting, and putting in mental effort. The research suggests that managers can do more to diagnose the motivation problems of employees.

When motivation goes off the rails, identifying exactly which trap has ensnared your employees — and applying just the right targeted intervention — can get things moving again. You have 1 free article s left this month. You are reading your last free article for this month. Subscribe for unlimited access. Create an account to read 2 more. Motivating people. Clark and Bror Saxberg. All Guides. Topics All Articles. Breathe News. Business Leadership. Business Process. Company Culture.

Employee Performance. Employment Law. Equality and Diversity. Flexible Working. Mental Health. Recruiting Talent. Remote Working. Login Free Trial.

Free trial. Back HR Software. Back HR Software Overview. Back Partners Partner Programme Overview. Back About Us Our Story. Back Resources Resources Hub. Back Topics All Articles. Language GB. What are motivation theories? What is motivation theory? So how do you motivate your employees and make them happier in the workplace? Motivation theories: the basics There are numerous branches of motivation theory but at its simplest, it boils down to two factors: Extrinsic factors.

Here people are motivated by external factors such as a bonus for hard work or a sanction if targets are not met. Intrinsic factors. Here people are motivated by a desire to satisfy human needs. These might include a desire to please their boss or to achieve certain professional or personal goals.

What tools do employers have to improve motivation? Reward — Receiving a bonus or raise can be all the incentive some need to work harder. But reward can take many different forms and could be something as simple as incentive pay or paid time off, gift vouchers or prizes for hitting targets, travel perks or health benefits. Trust —Employees want to know you have their best interests at heart while employers want to know they can trust employees to do a job well. Building a culture around trust creates a positive atmosphere which motivates your staff and benefits productivity.

It can also spur them on to achieve more. Career advancement —One study found that the number one reason for employees leaving their jobs was career development. It makes sense - employees want to use their skills.

They also want to learn new skills. Another example is when managers threaten job security to drive performance. In a wide-ranging study of employee motivation, Harvard Business School professor Teresa Amabile and psychologist Steven Kramer asked hundreds of employees to maintain a diary chronicling their peaks and valleys in motivation at work.

In fact, Amabile and Kramer talked with managers about what they thought was the single most important motivator for employees at work. Herzberg posited that factors like job recognition, potential for promotion, or even passion for the work itself could motivate an individual beyond the satisfaction of her or his basic needs. Non-hierarchical thinking about employee needs is important for your whole team — even your best performers. In a recent study by psychologist Susan David of highly engaged employees at work, David asked people what made them so engaged and excited about their work.

Evidence continues to build. Good managers will work with these employees to rebuild their self-confidence. For example, a leader I coach was about to launch a company-wide message to announce mandatory training on green solutions compliance. After reconsidering his approach, he created this message embedded with ways for people to experience autonomy, relatedness, and competence:.

There are three ways you can share our commitment for implementing green solutions as an essential part of our Corporate Social Responsibility initiative. You can choose any or all three options. Autonomy Let us know your preference s by email Autonomy by October 31 or stop by our table at the all-company Halloween party Relatedness. If you choose to opt out of all three choices Autonomy , please tell us what we can do to appeal more directly to your values around corporate social responsibility Relatedness.

You have 1 free article s left this month.